Log on to HSBC Internet Banking

Log On

Find out more  |  Register

H.K. Market Information



Stock Trading
Outlook for 2011 - Looking past the abyss
Highlights

  • 2011 proved an extremely volatile year, largely due to ongoing uncertainty surrounding the Eurozone sovereign debt situation.
  • Growth has slowed throughout the year, with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) cutting its 2011 Gross Domestic Product (GDP) economic growth forecast for developed economies from 2.5% to 1.6%.
  • Developed economies - with the US a major exception - are engaged in austerity measures while the emerging world is looking to dampen its much stronger growth to stave off any threat of inflation.
  • Any improvement in 2012 rests largely on the Eurozone finding an appropriate solution to its problems.
  • Against this background, many investors have fled to what they saw as safe havens, forcing gold prices to record highs and government bonds yields to generational lows.
  • Short-termism is rife in such volatile markets, creating opportunities in some asset classes for investors who can take a longer-term view.
  • Equities currently look to offer the best value, with many corporates in solid financial shape after applying their own austerity measures amid the credit crunch. Strong balance sheets are allowing ongoing dividend growth.
  • Share valuations remain low, reflecting the muted economic outlook in the developed markets. This ignores two key factors: that many developed market companies have growing emerging market earnings exposure, and the potential for emerging market equities to benefit from the region’s stronger macro outlook.
  • Core developed market government bonds represent poor value, with short-term safe haven investing forcing yields down. In some instances this asset class currently offers the prospect of negative real returns (returns after adjusting for inflation).
  • A combination of more persistent longer term inflation and the industrialisation of emerging markets favours physical assets like property and commodities. A positive supply and demand picture is also supportive for the latter.
  • Gold has proved popular as a safe haven, but with no yield the precious metal is challenging to value, and is likely to suffer when investors want to move into more risk orientated assets.
Markets looked into the abyss once again in 2011

Having started the year robustly enough, the outlook deteriorated sharply as the year progressed, with investors facing the prospect of recession (and some would argue depression) and even questioning the future of the financial system. Faultlines were evident early on, with civil unrest in the Middle East spreading to Libya and resulting in oil prices rising to a two-and-a-half year high. Japan then suffered a huge earthquake, tsunami and nuclear incident in March, causing supply chain issues for much of the year.

The real test for investor nerves came over the summer. Fears centred on Europe, with many nations suffering from high sovereign debt to GDP levels, budget deficits and low growth. While this focused on peripheral Europe until the autumn, signs of contagion spread to larger nations such as Italy and Spain as bond yields rose through 7% and 6% respectively. This in turn put pressure on the banking sector, a significant holder of sovereign debt, and concerns resurfaced that many in Europe would need to recapitalise or accelerate deleveraging (lowering debt levels). Furthermore, as bank funding costs rose, their ability to finance themselves was restricted, preventing them from supplying credit to the real economy. Another challenge faced by markets was one of slowing economic growth. Global growth had been recovering steadily since the end of the recession caused by the 2008 financial crisis (albeit rather unevenly, with muted growth in developed regions and much stronger figures in emerging markets).

Moving through 2011 however, this growth started to fall rapidly. In January, the IMF forecast 2011 GDP growth in advanced economies of 2.5% but had already revised this down to 1.6% by September. Emerging economies continued to benefit from structural growth drivers but were not completely immune from the slowdown in the developed world, having to raise interest rates in their battle against inflation. As a result, the IMF cut its 2011 growth forecast from 6.5% to 6.4%. All in all, the combination of slowing economic growth and fears that the euro and even the European Union may cease to exist in their current forms saw investors flee riskier investment categories such as equities and commodities. They looked for solace in traditionally defensive areas such as 'safe haven' government bonds and gold. Unusually high levels of volatility in the value of different types of investments were evident for much of the year.

Outlook for 2012

Central to any outlook for 2012 is that European authorities deliver a comprehensive solution to the ongoing Eurozone sovereign debt crisis. Officials have been applying a 'sticking plaster' approach to their problems: rather than tackling things early, politicians have only acted when faced with severe market pressure, and only then delivering just enough to stem the tide. This only served to highlight the fundamental inadequacies of the Eurozone's structures. Such a too little, too late approach is rarely an answer to market problems - investors invariably move onto the next problem and often, what started as a small issue quickly escalates into something far more serious. The situation in Europe over summer serves as an example. Almost from day one, investors deemed the package to bail out Greece as inadequate.

They quickly moved on to attack the systematically far more important Spanish and Italian government bond markets, forcing yields up to unprecedented.

Global economic growth is likely to remain under pressure. This is partly due to many developed economies instigating austerity packages and emerging markets stepping on the brakes to slow a growing inflation threat - but Europe is clearly compounding the problem. Despite many European companies being in relatively robust financial positions, they have simply stopped investing, preferring to wait until confidence increases before spending their cash.

In the face of such uncertainty, how can investors position a portfolio and even continue to hold more risky asset classes? Perhaps the best answer to this is encapsulated by Warren Buffett, who said 'be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful'.

The shift to short-termism

Underlying these words though is something far more fundamental. In short, markets have gone from being dominated by investors with longer-term investment horizons to being driven by short-termism. To a large degree this is understandable. When volatility is high, as it is now, investors quickly turn from targeting wealth generation to focusing on preserving it. The prospect of seeing hard-earned capital fall sharply in value is simply too much for many investors to bear. They would rather avoid riskier areas and invest in more conservative asset classes, even if the latter appear expensive in the long term. Compounding this shift to short-term investing though are some deeper, structural trends within world stock markets. Historically, pension funds were classic long-term investors. They had long-term liabilities and needed to invest in assets that could grow to meet these - importantly, short-term volatility was not a major concern and seen as a price worth paying for capital growth.

More recently though, there has been a shift in behaviour, with many funds now no longer targeting future liabilities but rather focusing on contributions. The need for holding risk asset classes has fallen, with bonds doing the job regardless of whether or not they generate value in the long term. We see this as a fundamental weakness in how individuals fund their retirement. Further, regulation is such that many funds have been required to sell down their riskier asset classes and switch into bonds. The rise of hedge funds and high frequency investors has exacerbated this problem by accentuating volatility further.

Here though is the opportunity for investors prepared and able to invest for the longer term; short-termism creates some exceptional investment opportunities.

The case for equities

If you can look through the short-term fog, equities offer some excellent opportunities for building wealth in the longer term, as part of a balanced portfolio. Companies, in contrast to governments and the consumers, have been managing themselves extremely prudently. While the former were building debt to unsustainable levels, companies were paying down borrowing and building cash balances. Equity dividend yields currently stand at attractive levels compared with government bonds, while company balance sheets are enabling them to grow dividends - a very attractive combination in a low interest rate environment.

Valuations are also extremely low by past standards. To some degree, this is justified with growth in developed economies likely to be somewhat lower than it was historically. But focusing on lower growth rates in developed economies ignores two key features. First, companies in developed markets are increasingly global in their outlook. They are not just a play on the economic growth of the country of their domicile, but instead can benefit from higher global growth.

Second, emerging market equities themselves offer investors the opportunity to benefit from the positive structural growth trends exhibited by developing economies. That said, performance of many emerging markets in 2011 shows they are not self-sufficient yet, with a high reliance on exports to the developed world. As they continue to grow however, there will inevitably be greater spending on domestic infrastructure and an increasingly wealthy population will look to consume more. This will reduce the dependence on exports and with it, make emerging market economies and possibly stock markets increasingly guardians of their own destinies.

The case against government bonds

The mirror image of this value in equities is the overvaluation within many government bond markets, with yields in many cases not sufficient enough to cover inflation. Government bonds have not only been one of the main beneficiaries of the shift to short-termism but also the long-term down trend in global inflation and interest rates. Again, much of this has been driven by emerging markets, which have increasingly become the manufacturing engine of the global economy.

This phenomenon has had two related impacts, with both driving down bond yields. First, by exporting cheaper consumer goods into developed economies, inflation rates have been held down. Second, these exports have created significant current account surpluses within developing markets, which have in many cases been recycled into government bonds, further pushing down yields.

While inflationary pressures look muted in the near-term as austerity packages in the developed world kick-in, we see the structural downtrend in inflation coming to an end. Wages in many emerging markets are now rising rapidly as these economies grow richer and their workers demand higher wages.

Also, as the global economy rebalances over the long term, the flows into developed market government bonds of recent years are unlikely to be repeated. Hence bonds have been the beneficiary of an almost perfect storm - a long-term downward shift in yields, accelerated by investors' pursuing safety in the short term. However, surely just as the bond evangelists' calls for structurally lower yields become more vocal, investors with a long-term outlook should be avoiding this category given the prospect of negative real long-term returns.

On the other hand, corporate bonds offer better value. Many companies are in good financial shape, having controlled costs to retain profits. Corporate default rates remain low and low interest rates continue to provide ample liquidity. Within fixed income, we prefer corporate debt for these reasons, especially in Asia where the region is supported by stronger fundamentals.

Equity Markets

US:
  • The outlook for the US economy remains tough, particularly as unemployment is stubbornly high at about 9%, with consumer spending a key driver of growth. However, the US does appear to be seeing stronger growth than other developed economies. This may provide some support to 2012 corporate earnings, at least compared with other developed markets, especially if economic stimulus measures are extended into 2012. Although valuations are somewhat higher than other developed markets, with a 2012 forecast price/earnings ratio of 10.9 times, we consider this a fair premium given the stronger economic momentum. Political deadlock has been a severe impediment to the US dealing with its budgetary problems, with the country standing alone among major economies in not enacting fiscal austerity. 2012 sees presidential and congressional elections and we would hope that post the primary stages of the contest, which are likely to see candidates appeal to their narrow party bases, they seek common ground and realistic ways of resolving the long-term budget pressures.
Europe:
  • Prospects for continental Europe remain dominated by the Eurozone debt crisis and the ability of politicians to arrive at a permanent resolution to the problem. European equities trade on a low multiple of 8.8 times forward earnings, implying the asset class offers significant value should a solution be found. However, the debt crisis is already having an impact on the European economy with Purchasing Managers Index (PMI) manufacturing and services indices moving firmly into contraction territory in October. A break-up of the Eurozone, which is not our central scenario, would have severe negative implications for the European economy and equities would likely see significant downside in this event.
  • We have a more positive view on UK equities. They benefit from significant exposure to international economies. Many companies enjoy robust balance sheets and the equity market also tends to exhibit defensive characteristics, which should be supportive in times of economic uncertainty. Valuations are attractive, on a forward earnings ratio of about 8.6 times (compared to a 10-year average of about 14 times) and a dividend yield of about 3.6%.
Japan:
  • Japanese equities frequently traded in a disconnected manner from other markets in 2011. Like other equity markets, valuations remain attractive, particularly if Japanese companies can boost their levels of return on equity, although this is likely to be a longer-term development. For 2012, Japanese equities are likely to be affected by the slowdown in global growth, while we would also expect appreciation to dampen corporate performance.
Asia ex-Japan:
  • The slowdown in global economic activity has had an impact on Asia ex Japan, given its relatively high levels of exports to developed countries. However, we still view the economic backdrop favourably, with its economies offering stronger growth than the developed world. Inflation is showing signs of moderating and we could see loosening monetary policies in 2012, which we would regard as positive for the region's economies and equity markets. Within Asia ex Japan, we favour Chinese equities where valuations are low in our view, with the market trading on about 8.2 times 2012 earnings, significantly below the market's 10-year average of about 12.5 times. There are risks in that the rapid rises in residential real estate prices could reverse and become destabilising to parts of the economy, but overall, we forecast a soft rather than a hard landing for the economy and forecast 2012 economic growth of around 8%.
Hong Kong and China:
  • Previous policy tightening measures in China coupled with a subdued global growth profile are beginning to slow economic growth and bring inflation down. GDP figures suggest sluggish growth in Hong Kong but the economy continues to enjoy low unemployment. Worries over the international economic picture and in particular concerns over sovereign debt in the Eurozone have dominated stock market sentiment in recent months and are likely to continue to do so. However, the superior ability to combat any global weakness give China and Hong Kong an advantage compared to other developed economies.
  • The Chinese government recently cut the Reserve Ratio Requirement by 50 basis points to 21% effective 5 December 2011. As global growth cools and inflation recedes, authorities have the latitude to further ease monetary policy, and further reductions in the RRR are quite likely. This could have a positive impact on market sentiment. We reiterate our preference to Chinese equities over other Asian markets because of the attractive valuation and robust growth profile.
Global Emerging Markets:
  • Emerging market equities have underperformed developed market equities in 2011. There is some risk that further downward revisions in global growth could lead to them continuing to trade as higher-risk plays rather than reflecting the superior structural features of their economies. However, valuations are attractive with aggregate emerging market equities trading on about 9 times 2012's earnings, against a 10-year average of about 11 times.
  • Within Eastern Europe, we favour Russian equities, where valuations remain low at about 4.9 times earnings (against a 10-year average of about 8 times). The country is a play on oil and other hard commodities where we have positive views.
  • Latin American equities are also extremely attractively valued on a P/E ratio of 9 times 2012 forward earnings, compared with a five-year average of 11.4 times. Despite slowing worldwide demand and falling commodity prices, commodity supplies remain tight overall and, so far, the likelihood of a crash similar to that of 2008/2009 seems low. On a macroeconomic level, many Latin American countries are in better shape than their developed market peers, supported by higher levels of consumer confidence and solid fiscal accounts.
Fixed Income

US Government Bonds:
  • US government bonds yields remain extremely low despite investors losing confidence in the role of political institutions to tackle fundamental budgetary problems. The US Congressional Budget Super Committee failed to reach a bipartisan deficit reduction agreement after three months of intense negotiations, despite a similar political deadlock over the summer leading to the US credit rating being downgraded by one notch by Standard & Poor's. More positively for treasuries, the Federal Reserve decided to lengthen the average maturity of its treasury holdings by selling USD400bn of short-dated securities and purchasing longer-term bonds. They also committed to keep Fed fund rates low for a longer period of time. Notwithstanding Federal Reserve actions that are currently supporting prices, we remain cautiously negative on US treasuries as an asset class. We believe the positive surprise seen in economic data can continue and should the Eurozone reach agreement on a lasting solution to its sovereign debt crisis, the safe haven premium embedded in US treasury prices may start to evaporate. This would force yields to rise to levels more reflective of the current economic and fiscal backdrop.
Eurozone Government Bonds:
  • The outlook for the Eurozone economy has significantly deteriorated over the last quarter. Economists are now forecasting a mild technical recession (two consecutive quarters of negative real output growth) in 2012. Countries with high debt and/or budget deficit ratios witnessed their funding cost surging to all-time highs since the euro was launched, with Italian and Spanish yields causing particular concern. Even core economies supposed to be immune to peripheral contagion saw government bond yields rising well above corresponding German benchmark yields. The probability of a Eurozone break-up has increased, but although the situation is difficult to predict, we would anticipate politicians will eventually establish a decisive programme to restore market confidence as the collateral damage would be so severe. This may imply a stricter application of a revised Stability and Growth Pact over the medium term, opening the way for a more drastic involvement of the European Central Bank in the short term. Overall, we are cautious on the more 'distressed' European sovereigns as well as on German Bunds due to the low yields on offer, with a resolution to the Eurozone's problems leaving Germany with additional financial obligations.
Sovereign Emerging Markets Debt:
  • Emerging market debt markets have seen a transformation over recent years, with countries showing significantly improved fiscal positions and trade balances as well as robust economic growth. Valuations remain reasonable and we see emerging market sovereign bonds outperforming the ‘safe haven’ developed economy bond markets, the latter of which offer very low yields to investors in our view.
Asian Government Bonds:
  • Fears of a coordinated global slowdown raise concerns that defaults will rise around the world. However the clearly superior relative strength of Asian economies means both sovereign and corporate issues have good credit profiles and represent attractive value at current spreads. Overall, we are positive on Asian USD bonds, but believe that the market could remain volatile given the uncertain global background.
Currency
  • Many currency markets have been driven by similar factors as equities and bonds, such as the Swiss franc, for example, which has seen significant appreciation. We would see a resolution of the Eurozone sovereign debt crisis as positive for the euro and negative for the Swiss franc, and possibly the dollar and yen, should such a resolution be accompanied by a wider increase in risk appetite. Longer term, we see the emerging market currencies as well placed to appreciate, reflecting their long-term structural advantages, although policy actions may slow down the process.

Source: HSBC Global Asset Management, Thomson Datastream, Bloomberg, Barclays, Consensus Economics, MLX

This document has been distributed by The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited (the "Bank") in the conduct of Hong Kong regulated business. It is not intended for anyone other than the recipient and should not be distributed by the recipient to any other persons. It may not be reproduced or further distributed.

Whilst every care has been taken in preparing this document, the Bank makes no guarantee, representation or warranty to its accuracy or completeness, and under no circumstances will the Bank be liable for any loss caused by reliance on any opinion or statement made in this document. Except as specifically indicated, the expressions of opinion are those of the Bank only and are subject to change without notice. Some of the information in this document is derived from third party sources as specified at the relevant places where such information is set out. The Bank believes such information to be reliable but it has not independently verified.

The information contained in this document has not been reviewed in the light of your personal financial circumstances. The Bank is not providing any financial or investment advice. The information is not and should not be construed as an offer to buy or sell any financial products, and should not be considered as investment advice.

Investment involves risk, value of investment may move up or down, and may become valueless. Past performance figures shown are not indicative of future performance. You should carefully consider whether any investment views and investment products are appropriate in view of your investment experience, objectives, financial resources and relevant circumstances. The relevant product offering documents should be read for further details.

The investment decision is yours but you should not invest in any product unless the intermediary who sells it to you has explained to you that the product is suitable for you having regard to your financial situation, investment experience and investment objectives.

This document has not been reviewed by the Securities and Futures Commission of Hong Kong or any regulatory authority in Hong Kong.

Issued by The Hongkong Shanghai Banking Corporation Limited

For more information, please call the following hotlines:
- HSBC Premier Customers (852) 2233 3322
- HSBC Advance Customers (852) 2748 8333
- SmartVantage Customers (852) 2233 3000